in the heart of historic bethlehem   •   534 Main Street Bethlehem, PA 18018   •   610.861.7631

A Nip, a Toot, a Tot, a Half…
or a Wee Dram

Growing up with Hot Toddys and Hot Ports as a winter warmer and family favourites gives a love and respect for whiskey.  A visit to McCarthy’s Red Stag Pub will include a fabulous selection of unique whiskeys from around the world, as well as various beers from Ireland, Scotland and the United States. A sample of our famous McCarthy’s Irish Cream is a must try in a French Pressed Coffee, as a mix in a cocktail, or simply on the rocks. If you’re lucky, you might also find it in one of our luscious desserts made special in-house (yummmm!).

Whether you’re looking to try a whiskey from Scotland, Ireland, Japan (yes, we have whiskey from Japan) or even the United States, we offer OVER 200 VARIETIES!  

Browse our Whiskey Menu

Monthly Whiskey Tastings!

Join us each month for an evening of fun and education as we sample a different whiskey, guided by our knowledgeable whiskey representatives.

All Tastings begin at 7:30 PM, and last for approximately one hour.
$25 Admisson • Ages 21+ only, please

Loading Events

Upcoming Events › Red Stag Whiskey Tastings

July 2021

Red White and Balvenie Whiskey Tasting

red white and balvenie

  Join us for our July Red White and Balvenie Whiskey Tasting at McCarthy’s Red Stag Pub and Whiskey Bar ABOUT THIS EVENT Join us in our Great Room for a safe private whiskey tasting conducted by our in house Whisky Ambassadors and staff. The July Red White and Balvenie Whiskey Tasting features Balvenie Whiskies perfectly paired with small bites to contrast the whiskey profiles and to enjoy! What to eat? Bacon wrapped dates w goat cheese Sinful Cake (Devils…

Find out more »
+ Export Events

Our Famous McCarthy’s Irish Coffee

McCarthy’s Irish Cream is a recipe from my mother from 2nd World War Northern Ireland, which we serve at The Red Stag as our “much better than Baileys” Liqueur. It can also be incorporated in our McCarthy’s Irish Cream Coffee. If you don’t love it, we’ll be really surprised.


McCarthy's Irish Coffee

Irish Coffee was developed in Ireland by Joe Sheridan, a restaurant owner in Foynes County Kerry early in the 1940s as a ploy to attract American visitors who landed in flying boats (the first regular Trans Atlantic crossings) on the River Shannon and docked at his jetty. Armed with the knowledge that Americans loved coffee and sweet cream ladened items, he devised one of our favourite beverages.  The Irish Coffee became popularized in the USA when Joe Sheridan took a position at the famed Buena Vista Cafe in San Francisco and made it a staple on their menu. Sheridan’s Irish Cream ,which comes in a split bottle with the black on one side and the cream on the other, is poured to look like an Irish Coffee, and just as in the original drink, is designed so the coffee is sipped through the cream. Other Irish Cream Liqueurs such as Bailey’s became popular over the years — but we think you’ll agree that our own version is by far the best.


Meet us in the Snug.

Whiskey Snug

What is a Snug?

Back in Ireland in “years gone by”, women weren’t really welcome in pubs (at least reputable women), so many pubs built Snugs to provide a safe haven inside the pub. We have three Snugs in The RSP, inspired by the Crowne Saloon in Belfast, Northern Ireland. We think you will love the ambiance, great for a private lunch meeting, a Marriage Proposal, or just a place to hang out with friends on a weekend.

McCarthy’s Red Stag Pub now has three Whiskey Snugs where you can dine, chat, and enjoy your time with friends and family…or strangers if you wish. 

The three snugs are named:  The Dog Snug, Snug 2, and Snug 3.  Try one out for yourself!

Become a Red Stag Pub Member and get special discounts, VIP event information and more delivered straight to your inbox.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

celtic cooking, baking & cocktails:

Grab your apron and join our classes!

Red Stag Pub